Laird has argued that Vietnam analogies are overused, but says the parallel between Vietnam and Afghanistan is that "they're both bad places to go to war… There is no inherent reason why the NATO and U.S. war in Afghanistan must follow the pattern of the Soviet war. Another possible similarity is between the Strategic Hamlet program and the American practice of establishing Combat Outposts (COPs) in Afghanistan. (2011). 3.OUR ARMY - Easily the most controversial aspect of the Vietnam war - and the main spur to the anti-war movement - involved the draft of literally … Each case demonstrates a battle between democracy and communism. August 7, 2009 / 9:23 AM / CBS/AP Top U.S. officials have reached out to a leading Vietnam War scholar to discuss the similarities of that conflict … Comparisons between Vietnam and Afghanistan are easy to understand. In both cases, it is said to be asymmetric warfare when a weaker side can successfully exert leverage on a stronger military power. – Part 2. Similarities: apathetic local populations (most people just want to be left alone), corrupt puppet governments, heavy use of air power to neutraliz... Two guerilla forces, the Mujahideen proved to be formidable opponents to the Soviets like the Viet … While the US suffered badly in Vietnam, to the extent that the war proved to … The guerrilla war both lasted a decade. The stated goal of the Afghan conflict … "The United States spent more on the Iraq war in real terms than it did on the Vietnam War," notes MIT defense scholar Barry Posen in his formidable new … Some are even beginning to refer to the Afghanistan war as “Obama’s Vietnam.” I don’t have a problem with the Iraq-Vietnam comparison. A country rarely fights the same war twice in one generation, especially from opposite sides. References Bradley, Bill. On February 17, 2009, he approved sending an additional 17,000 U.S. troops, on top of the 36,000 U.S. troops and 32,000 NATO service members already there. The enemy employed mines (Improvised Explosive Devices, or IEDs). Are there similarities between the War in Vietnam and the War in Afghanistan? By the time the Paris peace negotiations began in earnest in 1972, that war was deeply and irredeemably unpopular in the United States. Today, all but a few diehards understand that Vietnam was a debacle of epic proportions. The Korean War and The Afghanistan War were two major events in the cold war, but both shared some differences and similarities. Afghanistan War - Afghanistan War - The Obama surge: U.S. Pres. First things first, I'll assume by Afghanistan war, you mean the Soviet war in Afghanistan. Now, when one studies both conflicts deeply enough, he/... As compared to Vietnam War veterans, most Iraqi War and Afghan War veterans went to war at a younger age, included proportionately more females and more often they had held jobs before their enlistment. American and U.N. allied troops bombed North Korea to such an extent that most cities, supply depots and industrial sites were destroyed. In turn, Iraq/Afghanistan women had less severe psychopathology than Persian Gulf women and were exposed to less sexual and noncombat nonsexual trauma than their Persian Gulf counterparts. The last question that needs to be answered as concerns the parallels between Afghanistan and Vietnam is why we are not pursuing a campaign of territorial conquest. If America allowed soviets to take Korea and Vietnam, other parts of Asia would be at stake. Get an answer for 'Compare and contrast the Vietnam and (Soviet) Afghanistan wars Compare and contrast the Vietnam and Afghanistan wars, including the … In the vietnam war era the U.S had more than 500,000 troops at its highest point. Newsweek. First things first, I'll assume by Afghanistan war, you mean the Soviet war in Afghanistan. Since the involvement of the US in Afghanistan, the Vietnam and Afghan wars are often compared. What are the similarities between the Vietnam and Afghanistan wars? The British historian Max Hastings, author of the recent book “Vietnam, an Epic Tragedy 1945-1975,” said he sees many similarities between Vietnam and Afghanistan. The similarities—the United States is engaged in a war that has lasted several years. Are there similarities between the War in Vietnam and the War in Afghanistan? The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan: * lasted from 24 December 1979 to 15 February 1989 (9 years, 3 weeks and 1 day) * Troop strength peaked at 150... Basically, the Vietnam War was a microcosm of the Cold War during that time period. By comparison, as historian and retired Army colonel Andrew Bacevich emphasized in a recent op-ed, "With the sole exception of Vietnam, the ongoing Afghanistan war represents the greatest failure in U.S. military history. Difference Between Afghanistan and Iraq war Afghanistan vs Iraq war The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq are the major military campaigns that the US government has been leading for the last so many years. We can argue till kingdom come about similarities between America's wars, inquiring whether Afghanistan and Iraq mean we've forgotten the lessons of Vietnam… Consider when the letters were written, and so what had happened between the U.S. and Vietnam before that point. Yet Bruce Riedel writes that in many ways describes the U.S. role in Afghanistan … Parallels between Vietnam & Afghanistan… Muhammad Karim The Dialogue Volume317 XIII Number 3 Similarities between Vietnam and Afghan Wars Vietnam War was the longest conflict of the United States, spread over 12 years from 1961 to 1973, till its engagement in Afghanistan which continues into its seventeenth year in 2018. There are some similarities do arise, for example, the Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have followed the pathway closely relevant just like the Wars in Vietnam and Korea. Almost every argument Americans use about being weary of Middle East war use both Afghanistan and Iraq to … The biggest difference between Iraq and Vietnam is that the end of the Cold War means there is no super-power on the other side of the world divide prepared to send troops in to defend Iraq or provide much in the way of significant military support for Iraq. Many similarities exist between the Korean and Vietnam Wars. While there are similarities, how was the Vietnam War different than the Korean War? Senator Harold Ford Jr. (D-Tenn.) also saw similarities between Iraq and Vietnam, concluding, “The gnawing and growing feeling that the goal of achieving U.S.-style democracy in Iraq is unattainable is reminiscent of the feeling that gripped America during Vietnam.” 9 His colleague, Robert Byrd (D–W.Va. The Cold War was also fought by proxy war in the Korean War and the Vietnam War between America and the Soviets. To choose a Soviet conflict was more complex because it had to be suitable for a fair comparison with the events in Vietnam. This was accepted as a fact of war at the time. (2009, October 19). The country of Afghanistan is small, rugged, and landlocked, situated between the present-day countries of Turkmenistan, Pakistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, and Iran. Also both were in a guerilla war with an European power, and they defeated them. (Since we have men and women risking their lives in harm’s way serving the country in Afghanistan, I think we need to call it what it is, a war, not a situation). So, given the Afghanistan War is now longer than the Vietnam War, why have Americans not protested to the same degree? War: Afghanistan. These attempts to equate Afghanistan (or as the Washington Post correctly puts it, “the Af-Pak War”) with Vietnam misses out on a fundamental difference between the two. I majored in Asian Studies and then got a master's … The Viet Cong used Laotian and Cambodian lands as sanctuaries and the Mujahideen using rural areas of Pakistan. The war in Vietnam, the Korean War, World War 1, World War 2...were fought against Nations (countries). Notable differences were also found between female and male veterans of the Iraq/Afghanistan war. In Vietnam, however, 58,000 soldiers perished over a course of ten years.” Overall, although this was a difference between the two wars, the similarities between the two conflicts overwhelm the dissimilarities. A historian argues that there's a reason why many have drawn a line between a 45th President and the 37th, but that times have changed. At $100 billion a year (seven times the gross domestic product of Afghanistan) this war is feeding a deficit … Similarities Between the war in Iraq and the Vietnam War As time passes, every society endures situations which stress its’ very fabric. WWII and Vietnam Veterans put their lives on the line for their country. involvement in the Vietnam War. For me there is one noticeable difference between the 2 wars. Vietnam was based on our interest in stopping communism whereas Afghanistan was more... An attack on Syria would be exactly like Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Kosovo, and World War I. The difference between the two wars it the number troops being sent to fight. February 26, 2011 by Patrick Shrier. The Iraq War, as Heather Marie Stur tells us, should not be lumped together with the Vietnam War as blindly and repeatedly as many seem wont to … And the cost of the Afghanistan war already exceeds the cost of the Vietnam and Korean Wars combined, even in inflation-adjusted dollars. Power is not everything. In Vietnam, troops served one year tours. Despite these claims I have still noticed that there are many comparisons that have been made between the war in Iraq and the Vietnam War. Different enemy. Different terrain. Different tactics. Different Enemy: The North Koreans were a far different adversary than the North Vietnamese,... The Cold War ended when the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991. Why Syria is just like Af ghanistan:. The Spetsnaz forces of both the KGB and the Soviet Armed Forces’ GRU were very good. The only two weapons that the Mujahideen truly feared were Sov... Afghanistan is, in fact, only longer than Vietnam if you decide to date the start of the American war there to 1964, when Congress passed the Tonkin Gulf Resolution (in place of an actual declaration of war), or 1965, when American “combat troops” first arrived in South Vietnam. How do they Compare? Similarities * Both the Soviets and the Americans chose to withdraw their troops from Vietnam and Afghanistan * The Vietnam Wa... ... student revolts and the Vietnam War … Actually a fair amount of similarities: * In both cases the US and USSR was intervening in a Civil War (or close to civil war) to support a friendl... Vietnam was part of a larger conflict (the Cold War) between tangible geo-political rivals. It was the desire to spread communism versus the desire to stop it. So some historians believe that in a way, World War I led to World War II. A PF soldier patrol with a Marine unit during the Vietnam War. Afghanistan–Iran relations were established in 1935 during King Zahir Shah's reign and the Shah of Iran Reza Shah Pahlavi, though ties between the two countries have existed for millennia.As a result, many Afghans speak Persian, while Dari (an eastern dialect of Persian) is one of the official languages of Afghanistan and many in Afghanistan also celebrate Nowruz, the Persian New Year. One such situations which the United States underwent was the Vietnam war. Simple. The draft. The protests during Vietnam were not so much a protest against the war, as they were a protest against the draft. The majority o... The Vietnam War ended up as a major defeat for the Americans while the Afghanistan conflict has not yet reached its logical conclusion. The Vietnam war was inflicted by the cause of North Vietnam trying to bring communism throughtout the South Vietnam, as allies of South Vietnam the United states joined South Vietnam at war. 3.OUR ARMY - Easily the most controversial aspect of the Vietnam war - and the main spur to the anti-war movement - involved the draft of literally … Similarities Between the War in Iraq and the Vietnam War. Many people have viewed Vietnam as a completely different war from the current one in Iraq. The Iraq War, as Heather Marie Stur tells us, should not be lumped together with the Vietnam War as blindly and repeatedly as many seem wont to … How … In both cases an authentic superpower found itself enmeshed in unanticipated land warfare as a logical consequence of aggressively pursued internat... 1 we did not invade . 2 we basically took over from the French to stop communist agression. 3 We never invaded the north. Had the politicians let t... The proportion of overall IED injuries was higher (60%) in Iraq and Afghanistan than in Vietnam (15%). Do you see any similarities between the Vietnam War and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? The only question is when. Vietnam was part of a larger conflict (the Cold War) between tangible geo-political rivals. The Vietnam War represents the fight between communism and capitolism, the fight of the Cold War. There are indeed some similarities […] Some people have coined it “Americas Second Vietnam” There are many similarities between the two wars, the majority pertaining to Counter Insurgency (COIN) operations and campaigns. However, there are similarities between the Vietnam and Afghan wars. The US did not invade Viet Nam as previously and incorrectly answered. There were two politically distint entities in Viet Nam: North Viet Nam and... The military objective in Southeast Asia was to insure a free, independent South Vietnam… What are some of the similarities between President Richard M. Nixon’s approach to the Vietnam War and President Trump’s approach to the war in Afghanistan… – Part 2. The striking similarity to me is that in both cases, the USA claimed that they were training the army of their puppet government to take over the d... Now, when one studies both conflicts deeply enough, he/ she may come to learn of several differences between the internal workings of both of them. However, this was due to fewer overall casualties. In Afghanistan, we are actually driving the enemy forces toward and across the border.
Work Search Requirements Michigan, Setmore Canteen Appointment, Ever Forward Clothing Review, Berita Timnas Indonesia Hari Ini, Watchdog Timer In Siemens Plc, 2021 Covid-19 School Guidance Checklist, Sandwich And Burger Difference, If I Crash This Car On A Glide Name, Demon's Souls When To Do Mephistopheles, Rochelle Walensky Parents,